Affirmative action was first created to create a more diverse environment. Although this still holds true, I believe that it has been taken way too far. I don't think affirmative action should be followed. Colleges and Universities should accept kids based on their academic, athletic, and leadership backgrounds, and not their ethnic backgrounds. If a school chooses it students that way, then it will be very tough for kids to call them racist, sexist, etc... Instead of having to meet quotas in terms of having a specific number of minorities, the school would be able to choose kids that would best fit their school. If this means less diversity, then so what? I don't disagree with schools trying to create a more diverse learning environment, but if it means taking spots away from more deserving kids, then it isn't right. It's different if 2 kids have the same grades, one's white and one's a minority, and a school wants to take the minority for more diversity. That's OK. But let's say there's an Asian kid and a Hispanic kid. The Asian kid has much better grades, but the school wants more Hispanic kids for diversity. So, the school takes the Hispanic kid...that's what creates problems. The best way to avoid those problems is to avoid the 'affirmative action' policies and choose kids based on what's important.
People may argue that having diversity creates a better learning environment. I'm a strong believer that everybody comes from different backgrounds and everybody has their own stories. Just because someone is from a different country or has a different skin color, doesn't mean they bring something extraordinarily different. I'm all for having diversity, but I don't think there's any need to force it.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteA bit confusing Jack. You say that you don't believe in AA but then you say this " if 2 kids have the same grades, one's white and one's a minority, and a school wants to take the minority for more diversity. That's OK" Isn't that affirmative action? Aren't they taking race into account? You have a strong opinion but you need to clarify and support it by using specifics and details from the unit.
ReplyDeleteYour blog overall is fun to read. There is a clear sense of your voice and who you are. Good! Keep that up but work to update far more consistently and to keep up with each of the required posts. There are too many missing here. Also, push yourself to go even further in expanding and explaining your ideas. To do so will make your blogging experience more meaningful for you and your readers.